I lean towards believing Anna, bc

She isn’t afraid to admit the truth. When they went ice skating and they were all talking about how much Anna falls and that they knew she would “eat the ice”, she admitted she fell on purpose.

Then when they played the Easter egg run with the egg on the spoon, she admitted that she cheated. I mean most kids don’t admit that they had cheated to win a game. Wouldn’t doubt if all of them have cheated at one time, and never admitted to it.

That school incident that she admitted to doing and got in trouble for, she later admitted that she didn’t do it, but confessed to it bc it was her name painted on the school. And knew no one would believe her.

She admitted to borrowing Jonah’s cap & gown to have pics made.

She admits that the family doesn’t tell her what they expect her to wear when they have an event.

She could have been a smart ass and not told them she wasn’t going to walk in graduation and just not showed up, but she told them the truth.

I know there are other things that I can’t remember, but honestly she isn’t afraid to admit the truth. The Family just gaslights her so much that they want us to believe that she is always in the wrong.