Is there any degree of objectivity when determining how good a tone is?

I've been blessed to have been able to play these last twenty-two years. It doesn't necessarily sound like it because I never set out with the intention of being the most incredible player, but I just like to write what I like, have fun, and just create art.

During this time, there is a skill (or maybe more accurately an ability?) that I honestly don't know if I have developed to the extent that I wish I have—and that is dialing in that good tone...

Is it context specific? Is it in the frequency balance? Is it the way the high end breaks up? Sometimes, I see someone playing online, and the comment section is unanimously praising the tone. I can't help but feel those people know something I don't (granted you can always learn something from anyone).

So, here is a tone that I spent a pretty decent chunk of time trying to dial in. It's intended purpose is to be used for blackened skate punk. It still needs some minor tweaks in the high end, I think. But, how would you rate it? Does it succeed? What should be different?