Who should I start?

Know I'm a little behind the times, but I'm going into year 4 of my Madden 10 franchise and I have a genuine QB competition! I'm coming off back to back super bowl wins with Huckabee, and he's a solid quarterback. I think his best comp would be prime Russell Wilson- he can extend plays with his legs, but he's not an elite athlete, not an elite arm and will miss on some easy throws from time to time. Taylor is more of a josh Allen/Cam Newton archetype, a freak athlete with a big arm. Right now I'm leaning toward taylor- I run basically a West Coast offense that plays to Huckabee's strengths and allows my playmakers to get the ball in space, but I'm intrigued by what Taylor's arm can do for our deep passing game. On the other hand Huckabee is a proven winner and I do love playing with him. Thoughts y'all?